to top

Last Week, I…

Quit breastfeeding.

Had to choose between quitting cold turkey and gradually quitting (by cutting out one pumping/nursing session every couple of days). Decided that engorgement pain is preferable to the razor-sharp pain from thrush I get every time my right breast is emptied. Smelled like cabbage soup as I stuffed my bra with cold cabbage leaves to help with the engorgement. Drank sage tea and Coke to help kill my milk supply. Regretted quitting more than once as my breasts became rock-hard and throbbed with pain. Leaked through numerous nursing pads, bras, and shirts.

Felt overwhelming guilt for not providing the best available nutrition for my child. Felt further burdened by “lactivists” online who likened formula to poison, who informed me that if I were not ready to make sacrifices for my child, I shouldn’t have gotten pregnant in the first place.

Realized these women know squat about my life or my family.

Did research and discovered that while breastmilk is best, it is only marginally better. Most studies that tout the benefits of breastmilk (or formula, for that matter) are so flawed/biased that there really is no conclusive evidence that children who are formula-fed are any less smart or healthy, or vice-versa. Correlation ≠ causation.

Realized that some of the healthiest, smartest, and most talented people I know were formula-fed as babies. People who are Ivy League graduates, have great jobs, hold MBAs and PhDs, are at top physical shapes and rarely get sick.

Cried tears of relief as I put away my pumping supplies.

Shed a few more tears the first day that Claire went 100% formula. Told her how sorry I was and that I had failed her as a mommy, that she must be patient as I will most likely fail her many more times in the future. Watched as she happily sucked away at her bottle of Similac Sensitive and looked at me as if to say, “I forgive you.”

Bonded more with my daughter in 5 days than I had with her in the entire past month. Was able to hold her tight (despite the painful engorgement in my chest) and not dread my next nursing/pumping session.

Realized that I had been associating my baby with pain, and that was now a thing of the past.

Gorged on Thanksgiving dinner without worrying about whether a dish had dairy, seafood, beans, broccoli, and all the other foods I had cut from my diet.

Had my first glass of wine in over 11 months and enjoyed every last drop.

Still experience guilt time to time. Am dreading Claire’s 3rd month checkup this Friday when the pediatrician is sure to ask if I am still breastfeeding. Have been reading sites such as Fearless Formula Feeder for encouragement and support.

Hopes that no one will judge me for this decision. After all, doesn’t a happy mommy help lead to a happy baby?

  • Nodakademic

    From the pain and suffering you've described, I'd never have lasted as long as you did. Good for you for making the healthy and rational choice for yourself and your baby. Like you said, if mommy's unhappy, she can't be the best mommy. Sounds like things are already looking up for you and Claire. [I think my mom made it ~2 months before she switched me to formula, and I turned out OK!]

    December 1, 2010 at 2:34 pm Reply
  • Bonnie

    Good for you! Many of my friends have done the same thing and NO ONE has any regrets. Also, my bro and I were totally formula-fed and we turned out fine! 🙂

    December 1, 2010 at 5:49 pm Reply
  • Lina

    HI! I followed your blog for some time now, and this is the first time I comment!
    Congrats on being happy again with your baby! And just feel good to stop breastfeeding. I did the same after 2 weeks of breastfeeding and I don't think my child is more deprived than other. As a mother, I think we should simply do what we feel good for our baby and not what society tell us to do!

    December 2, 2010 at 9:20 am Reply
  • Rachael

    Don't feel bad. What's best for your baby is absolutely you being with her, present and loving and enjoying her babyhood. Boob or no boob!

    December 2, 2010 at 10:20 pm Reply
  • Anita

    You know what is best. Good for you Jenny! I agree that now you can have more positive feelings about your baby which is really important since that bond is so important.

    December 2, 2010 at 10:25 pm Reply
  • Christine

    Congrats! I'm glad you're doing something that will be good for both you and your baby. I went into pre-mature labor and ended up having my baby four weeks early. Now that I'm nursing, I'm so engorged and the pain is killing me. I'm not sure if I have blocked ducts or not but its making me consider nursing only until i go back to work Best wishes to you guys!

    December 5, 2010 at 10:40 pm Reply
  • Lauren

    A happy mom is a better mom. Have you read "The Case Against Breastfeeding?" The content isn't as sensational as the title. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/04/the-case-against-breast-feeding/7311/

    December 6, 2010 at 5:20 am Reply
  • anon

    One of you was lazy and impatient, but it wasn’t your daughter.

    March 9, 2011 at 1:47 pm Reply
  • Adeline

    Hi. Can I ask how long does the engorgement period last? I am currently quitting breast feeding cold turkey. The pain is unbearable. I take vicodin and ibuprofen as needed. I just want to know how much longer do I need to tough it out. In my opinion, this is more painful than childbirth!

    April 4, 2011 at 12:03 pm Reply

Leave a Comment